Has the Zone 2 bubble burst? The backlash against a popular longevity exercise explains what you're doing wrong
Zone 2 cardio has real benefits, but experts say it's overhyped. Here's why mixing easy workouts with harder efforts may be better for longevity.
- Doing more easy cardio exercise has been touted as a key strategy for living longer and better.
- Steady movement is great for you, but it's not a magical formula for longevity or performance.
- On a tight schedule, high-intensity workouts are more efficient. A mix of easy and hard is ideal.
For years, Zone 2 workouts have been sold as one of the smartest ways to work out for longevity — go slow most of the time, push harder occasionally, and build endurance in between.
But the trend is being called into question. One morning in late October, I opened Instagram to find Dr. Peter Attia, the doctor and somewhat controversial longevity influencer who helped to popularize this cardio trend, saying he might have gotten something wrong.
"Of all the things I've really had to recommunicate with people, or maybe undo things that I had inadvertently done that may have set people on the wrong path, this is probably the area where I would have to eat the most crow," Attia said in the Instagram reel.
It turns out, everyone is ready for the Zone 2 bubble to burst.
After seeing Attia's post, I checked in with athletes, doctors, and researchers, who all told me that, while Zone 2 has plenty of health benefits, it has been overhyped and misunderstood — flattened into overly rigid advice. (I also reached out to Attia, who didn't provide a comment for this story.)
So, what now? I wanted to know whether those painstakingly slow runs — where I was getting passed on the sidewalk by Brooklyn grandmothers and moms with strollers — had actually helped.
The answer? Easy cardio has real benefits, but most people make two key mistakes when they treat it as a rule.
What's the big deal with Zone 2?
It all started in late 2019, when Attia interviewed top exercise physiologist and coach, Iñigo San Millán. Both avid cyclists, the two discussed the benefits of Zone 2 exercise — a conversational pace, about 60-70% of your max heart rate — for burning fat, building endurance, and supporting metabolic health.
Since then, Attia has strongly advocated for Zone 2 training as longevity exercise, an important tool for optimizing metabolism and mitochondrial health. Mitochondria, the powerhouses of cells, are a key source of energy, and protecting them is crucial for healthy aging.
Attia often suggested that about 80% of total cardio training volume should be around Zone 2, with the remaining 20% in higher intensities, to maximize mitochondrial improvements.
Pro athletes do a lot of exercise to stay at the top of their sport, and low-intensity work can help prevent injury or overtraining.
Billy Ceusters/Getty Images
It makes intuitive sense. Elite athletes spend a ton of time in Zone, and they're clearly doing something right. Fitness enthusiasts like me started focusing on more hours of easy running, rowing, or biking. It's an appealing prospect, chugging along at a comfortable pace, compared to the grueling HIIT sessions that had dominated the previous era of training.
But in recent years, evidence has accumulated to suggest that low-intensity work is no better than other forms of exercise for health and performance. It may even be less effective in some cases, said Brendon Gurd, professor of muscle physiology at Queen's University and senior author of a 2025 study on Zone 2.
"The message has been that you get this special benefit from that intensity of exercise. From our review, I don't think that's true," he told Business Insider.
That's not to say Zone 2 is worthless, but many of us misunderstand why it matters, according to endurance athlete and coach Manuel Sola Arjona. He's a huge proponent of low-intensity training — in the right context.
"The mistake is copying the professionals without understanding why they train that way: because they train a huge number of hours," he told Business Insider. "We believe Zone 2 is a magic intensity, when what really happens is that Zone 2 is the intensity that allows you to train many, many hours."
What zone should you be training in?
Don't cancel your weekly easy run just yet. The heart is a muscle; it needs to work to get stronger, and every bit of training counts. Understanding intensity can help you find the right way to train for your goals and your current fitness level, according to two doctors who specialize in endurance and longevity.
Working at high intensities can lead to faster results, said Dr. Brittany Busse, a marathon runner and precision medicine physician.
Bursts of hard work with short rests in between stress the body, prompting it to adapt to become more efficient, such as boosting your VO2 max — a key marker of cardio health linked to longevity.
"The longer work interval that you have and the shorter rest interval that you have, the more VO2 max bump you're going to see," Busse said.
Working out at maximum intensity is uncomfortable, and you'd need a lab test to accurately measure it.
jacoblund/Getty Images
The trade-off is that Zones 4 and 5 have high mental and physiological costs, and overtraining can backfire. Sports medicine specialist, trail runner, and cyclist Dr. Howard Luks sees a lot of athletes burn out by training too hard, too often.
"The key variable in training to be better or to live longer is consistency," he told Business Insider. "It's the tortoise and the hare story. The intensity junkie who gets injured has to stop."
The alternative is slow, steady work you can build on over weeks, months, and years while maintaining your progress.
"I don't care if my VO2 max goes up over 4 months; I want it to go up for 40 years," Luks said.
However, it's not very time-effective. To max out on the benefits of low-intensity exercise, you'd need to spend roughly 10 hours a week training, Luks said.
That's where a sprinkle of sprinting or other high-intensity work is important. Low-intensity work builds the fitness foundation, but likely won't be enough by itself.
"Zone 2 is like vegetables. It's the base of a balanced diet, and you can eat as much as you like. But a salad is very healthy and still leaves you hungry," Arjona said.
If your schedule is tight, you might be better off putting at least some of those hours into higher-intensity effort that gives you more bang for your buck, Arjona said.
"Five minutes in zone 4 produce far more adaptation than five minutes in zone 2," he said.
For many of us, spending too much time at Zone 2 risks leaving gains on the table — it should be a foundation to build on, not an end point, said Busse.
"You will get a big improvement right away in metabolic health and cardiovascular risk factors, all of these things from low-intensity exercise," she said. "If you want to keep moving up to optimized, then you're potentially switching from low-intensity to higher-intensity sessions."
Building a better longevity workout
There isn't a one-size-fits-all template for the perfect longevity workout. But the experts agree on a few basics.
First, forget the phrase "Zone 2" entirely, Luks said. Instead of fixating on heart rate numbers on your smartwatch, focus on perceived exertion — or, how hard something feels.
Pair low-intensity exercise, such as walking, with a bit of higher-intensity cardio and some strength training, gradually ramping up so you don't overdo what your body can handle.
Think about building a fitness portfolio by diversifying the time and energy you invest across a few different categories of exercise each week.
"If your time is limited, mixing in some harder efforts is often a more efficient way to get fitter," Antonio said.
Even a few minutes can help. Luks recommends ending a steady jog with a few cycles of sprinting uphill or fast strides for 15-30 seconds, with a short rest between efforts.
Finally, keep things in perspective. If your current workout routine is minimal, don't get distracted by trying to plan out the optimal program for seven days a week. Start by doing any movement you enjoy.
"The greatest jump in longevity comes from doing nothing to doing something," Luks said.
The post Has the Zone 2 bubble burst? The backlash against a popular longevity exercise explains what you're doing wrong appeared first on Business Insider